Blaming Oil Companies For Weather That Is NOT Getting Worse

A recent article at Maryland Matters says in its title “Maryland already pays for climate change; the question is whether polluters ever will”, arguing that Maryland is suffering the impacts of ‘climate change’ and that ‘fossil fuel’ companies should contribute to a “superfund” to pay for ‘climate damage’ to the state
This is false on multiple counts. First, Maryland is not suffering from ‘climate change’.
‘Extreme’ weather is NOT becoming more common, and carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions are NOT pollutants. It is absurd to hold local energy companies liable for supposed downstream impacts.
The Maryland Matters (MM) op-ed, written by Jamie DeMarco, a member of a climate commission for the state, describes a bill that has been proposed for Maryland.
The bill, called the RENEW Act, is being referred to a “climate superfund” bill. It “would ask the largest ‘fossil fuel’ companies to help cover what ‘extreme’ weather is costing the state, and lawmakers took the first step in 2025 by ordering a study of those costs, due this December.”
It is doubtful that lawmakers pushing this bill will actually examine Maryland’s weather history and data to support their case; if they did, they would find that the state is NOT suffering from increased extreme weather.
Already, the MM piece says the comptroller has forwarded the idea that 85 ‘extreme’ weather events over the past forty or so years have “cost Maryland $10 billion to $20 billion.”
DeMarco adds that “70 percent of Baltimore-area residents expect climate change to raise costs for homeowners and businesses in the next five years.”
Of course, a poll asking people what they believe based on misinformation spread by articles such as this one is not data, it’s not even evidence of anything but public miseducation.
Also referenced as supposed climate-caused storms were two floods from 2024 in Annapolis’ City Dock, as well as Tropical Storm Debby.
The problem is that data does not show Maryland seeing any increase in these kinds of disasters, which one would need to show in order to prove causation that could be linked to ‘climate change’, much less ‘climate change’ caused by energy companies.
Its simple, if there is no worsening of weather trends over time, then there is no evidence ‘climate change’ is making weather worse.
Tropical cyclones like hurricanes, tropical storms and depressions, as well as extratropical storms, show NO trend towards worsening or becoming more frequent, according to data going back to 1856. (See figure below)

If ‘climate change’ was behind Tropical Storm Debby, one would expect it to be part of a longer trend of intensifying or more frequent tropical storms, but it isn’t, nor is it unusual for Maryland to experience some tropical storm impacts.
Relative sea level rise for the Annapolis tide gauge station has been about 1.38 feet since 1928. That is a rate of 2.4 inches per decade. However, only part of that rise has to do with a change in actual sea water height relative to the coast.
Groundwater withdrawals are known to be causing land to sink on the East Coast, which is only exacerbated by population growth, alongside natural geologic processes and compaction.
The mean land subsidence rate of the Maryland Coastal Plain is about 2.3mm a year, according to a study from the Maryland Department of Natural Resources, which equates to just under one inch per decade of relative sea level rise due to subsidence alone.
The Maryland government should account for these facts before attributing such harms to ‘climate change’ and trying to bill energy companies for any damages due to flooding, which seems like a ridiculous undertaking even if one accepts the equally ridiculous idea that CO2 emissions from ‘fossil fuels’ are primarily responsible for sea level rise.
By the way, its not the oil companies producing the emissions, it is the people and industries in Maryland and around the world that use their legal products every day.
Repeated local flooding issues are much more an infrastructure problem, in part due to the increase in impermeable surfaces like concrete when cities expand and wetlands are taken over. It is far more connected to population increase than global warming.
Certainly, this requires funding to fix, but it’s not the responsibility of ‘fossil fuel’ producers, whose products will ironically be needed to fix the water management infrastructure.
The article calls CO2 “pollution,” but the levels in the atmosphere today are far from harmful. Rather they are essential for all life on Earth, and have in fact contributed to greater fertilization of plants.
Carbon dioxide is not ‘polluting’ anything.
As explained in the Climate Realism post, “Louisiana Did the Right Thing Blocking Climate Lawfare,” attempting to attribute sea level rise or storms to a particular company or industry is nonsense, because any one company operating in the state is responsible for an immeasurably small share of global emissions.
Oil and gas are necessary for the lifestyle that Maryland residents desire, much like anywhere else.
Cold temperatures in winter are deadly, so Marylanders turn on the heat, powered primarily by natural gas, followed by nuclear, then coal, with solar and wind making up just tiny fractions of the state’s electricity generation.
Marylanders are not going to give up driving cars or stop using steel, asphalt, concrete, or pharmaceuticals and other products that ‘fossil fuels’ are essential in the production of, to stop global warming.
Maryland families are responsible for emissions they generate themselves, and climate activists like the author of this post will eventually come for them as well, limiting their access to fuel and raising the cost of electricity.
DeMarco, and by extension the Maryland legislature and Maryland Matters are simply trying to fleece energy companies to fill in the gaps in state and local budgets.
The state has been irresponsible in funding disaster preparedness and infrastructure construction, maintenance, and repairs, and is trying to use oil companies as a scapegoat and funding source to make up for their own fiscal malfeasance.
See more here climatechangedispatch
