Critically Thinking about Water Filters
Sufficient clean water is arguably the single most important necessity for good health. That said, we often do not give this adequate attention
For example, most people buy water filters (e.g., for their refrigerator). We are drinking everything that comes through that filter. But where is it made and what quality control does it have?
If you look for water filters at Amazon, Walmart, etc., the lowest-priced options are almost all made in China. I have nothing against Chinese products in general, but it is legitimate to ask:
1) exactly what materials are in this filter, and
2) what quality controls are there assuring us that it works properly?
In my experience — as a scientist and as an individual who has been involved with water quality issues for many years — the typical answer to both of those questions for Chinesew filters is: we do not know.
Considering the potential impact on you and your family of drinking gallons of questionably filtered water, IMO, a good filter is not something where it makes sense to get the cheapest product.
I tried this Internet search, “What is the quality of water filters made in China?” but nothing relevant came up. Noteworthy is that most of the articles that did appear seemed to be of Chinese origin, promoting Chinese filters.
Two sites that list American-made water filters are here and here. Although these will be somewhat more expensive, you have a much higher assurance that you are getting a quality product.
My comments so far have been about filtering generally good water. If you have local water with specialized contaminants (e.g., PFAS), then you need specialized filters (e.g., here).
Buying Water —
Buying filtered water is a related topic, and has become an everyday affair for almost all of us. But here’s a question that you rarely see discussed — is it better to buy:
1) pre-packaged water, or
2) water from a vending machine?
Pre-packaged water would be in gallon to pint-sized plastic containers — readily available almost everywhere. The attraction is convenience. The main downsides are:
a) cost,
b) unknown filtration, and
c) plastic pollution in landfills and elsewhere.
Buying vending machine water is a popular alternative. The attractions are:
a) much lower cost ($2± vs 50¢± per gal),
b) high quality filtration, and
c) zero plastic pollution. The downside is convenience.
For the significant positive benefits, 95 percent of the time when we buy water, we use a vending machine.
We solve the convenience issue by filling up several gallon containers ahead of time, so that we have a supply on hand. If we are going for a walk and want an eight ounce container, we fill a reusable one up from our supply and are good to go.
Yes, this requires a bit of planning (horrors!), but the benefits are large.
The Bottom Line —
After the COVID fiasco, many of us are more attuned to the monumental importance of having good health.
Any serious health plan for you and your family MUST include close attention to drinking water and its filtration.
Sample reference: Safe Water and Your Health
See more here substack.com
Header image: Family Handyman
Please Donate Below To Support Our Ongoing Work To Defend The Scientific Method
PRINCIPIA SCIENTIFIC INTERNATIONAL, legally registered in the UK as a company 
incorporated for charitable purposes. Head Office: 27 Old Gloucester Street, London WC1N 3AX.
Trackback from your site.
JFK
| #
This “science” of ours is greatly improving our lives alright…
My grandparents had no healthcare, no electricity, and were drinking river-water directly from rivers, and outlived 99% of modern people, even those that protect themselves from everything one can think of.
Now you cannot find pure water or food or air anywhere.
And you may spend a fortune to obtain them, and still get nothing as good as we had some generations ago.
This is the elephant in the room, that no science-enthusiast wants to accept:
Technology rarely solves problems. Most of the times it transforms them into other problems, and usually worse.
And letting immature, greedy, narrow-minded, and over-optimistic people use technology at large is the fastest path to a complete disaster.
Reply
Anapat
| #
1000 % right! In France for example one can only sell modified water. So public servants pour some chlorine into it. Good for their bank account but bad for our health.
Reply