This was inspired from a comment by “richardengland”:
“Lets make it really simple: once the hot water has left the kettle can this hot water be made hotter without going back into the kettle and its heating coil? Yes or no.”
And I think that that is actually precisely it, with a slight modification:
Will putting your tea back into the kettle make the kettle hotter than when it poured your tea? That is exactly what they’re claiming when they say that “backradiation” from the atmosphere can heat the warmer surface, the warmer surface from where the thermal energy came from in the first place.




We must now look at Roy Spencer’s 
In total, the study found 67,000 square miles of water was converted into land, and 44,000 square miles of land was covered by water.
