Lancet Falsely Claims Global Warming Is Damaging Our Health

For the tenth year running, The Lancet, once one of the best-respected medical journals in the world, doubles down on the pretence that our health is suffering because of the current warming trend, and that people around the world are dropping like flies

The article states:

Accelerating health threats in a heating world

The past 11 years have been the hottest on record, and growing emissions mean overshooting the 1·5°C threshold is probably unavoidable—pushing the world beyond the limits needed to protect health. Indicators in this report show that, since the Paris Agreement entered into force in 2016, people have experienced not only increasing climate change-related health impacts and risks, but also an acceleration in these changes across numerous impacts compared with the previous decade. Although whether this acceleration will continue remains uncertain, it has already exacerbated adaptation challenges and claimed lives, harmed health, and affected wellbeing worldwide.

During 2016–23, heat was associated with an average of 540 800 deaths per year, of which 369 940 (68·4 percent) were attributable to human-caused climate change. Heat-related deaths reached a record-high of 710 000 estimated deaths globally in 2023, of which 71·5 percent can be attributed to climate change. Countries with a low human development index (HDI) had the highest proportion of heat-attributable deaths, reflecting the disproportionate adverse impacts of climate change on those least responsible for it, and the resulting amplification of global health inequities (indicator 1.1.5).

More frequent heatwaves and extreme droughts are increasingly threatening food security (indicator 1.4.1). Droughts affected 51·8 percent of global land for at least 1 month in 2025—the second-highest level recorded. This trend has accelerated, with the affected area growing 704 percent faster in 2016–25 than in 2006–15 (indicator 1.2.2). In parallel, the rate of increase in very extreme precipitation days, which in 2016–25 affected 17·2 percent of global land annually, has also accelerated, exacerbating the risk and occurrence of health-threatening floods and landslides (indicator 1.2.3).

Rising temperatures and changing rainfall patterns have also driven an accelerated increase in the environmental suitability for dengue virus transmission, and a record-high number of people (1·72 billion) lived within 100 km of coastal waters environmentally suitable for the transmission of Vibrio bacteria in 2025 (indicators 1.3.1 and 1.3.2). Climate change is also affecting malaria and West Nile virus transmission, reducing suitability in some areas while increasing it in others (indicator 1.3.1).

These health impacts have cascading effects on the economic conditions essential for good health. Globally, heat exposure caused the loss of 573 billion potential work hours in 2025, resulting in US$1·07 trillion in income losses. Low and medium HDI countries were most affected, with losses equivalent to five percent of gross domestic product (GDP) for low HDI countries and 3·7 percent of GDP for medium HDI countries, compared with one to four percent of GDP for high HDI countries and 0·5 percent of GDP for very high HDI countries (indicators 1.1.4 and 4.1.3). These unequal impacts reinforce the need for a just transition, in which countries that contributed the most to climate change provide meaningful support to those most affected and least responsible.

Source: thelancet.com

All of these silly claims have been debunked year after year, so this time I will focus on:

1) Claims of worsening drought

2) Heat related deaths

Drought

The Lancet Countdown claims there has been a large increase in drought conditions even in just the last ten years, itself a ludicrous statement, as the world’s climate does not change measurably on such short timescales.

Droughts, they say, affected 51·8 percent of global land for at least one month in 2025.

You won’t be surprised to learn that their claims are not based on actual precipitation data. Instead it is derived from computer models, known as the Standardised Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index:

If all this was true, they would not need computer models to prove it. The evidence, in terms of food production and health effects, would be overwhelming.

So let’s look at three countries particularly affected according to the report.

Pakistan

According to the map, Pakistan has experienced something like a 20 percent increase in the number of extremely dry months, when comparing 2016-25 with 2006-15.

But when you look at agricultural output, and in particular cereal production, there is no evidence at all for the crop losses claimed by The Lancet. On the contrary, both indices show continuing, uninterrupted growth, at the same rate or even better than the past.

And what about the supposed health impacts and “food insecurity”?

Well, blow me down! Life expectancy keeps getting longer and longer, interrupted only by the pandemic blip, while deaths from malnutrition keep falling as well:

This is exactly the opposite of the disaster implied by The Lancet.

(Editor’s note: there now follows ten graphs showing the same discrepancies in Brazil, Africa and the Sahara. See the source document)

Unsurprisingly, the claim that heat killed 710,000 in 2023 is not based on actual data, but flawed computer models. We have already seen that similar claims of heat deaths in Britain were contradicted by mortality data.

The mortality charts shown above for Pakistan, Brazil and Africa already make a nonsense of such claims, particularly Africa, which The Lancet lists as one of the most affected regions. They also completely undermine other Lancet claims of increasing health impacts from extreme weather.

But to put the figures into perspective, about 63 million die around the world each year.

710,000 may sound a lot, but it is a rounding error.

Moreover, another recent Lancet study estimated that, while there were 489,075 heat-related excess deaths a year, there were also 4,594,098 cold-related ones, that is eight times as many deaths from cold.

See below:

Why does this new study not give us both sets of numbers? A warmer climate, after all, will likely mean much lower deaths from cold.

Of course, that would not suit the Lancet’s agenda.

Source: thelancet.com

As with every other Lancet Countdown, this latest has no scientific value. Its only purpose is a political one, as the report’s conclusion makes clear:

See more here notalotofpeopleknowthat

Bold emphasis added

Please Donate Below To Support Our Ongoing Work To Defend The Scientific Method

Leave a comment

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.
Share via
Share via