Demolishing the Midwit War on Every Cheap Health Solution
If you’ve been following our magnesium series, you’ll know we recently published a four-part rebuttal to a set of articles claiming that magnesium supplements are industrial poison.
We disclosed upfront that we sell supplements and we laid out the independent research, the chemistry, and the clinical data.
The author’s response? She told her followers that “a few of the authors sell supplements.” As though she’d uncovered some hidden scandal. We’d said exactly that. In the opening paragraphs. Of the first article. Which she apparently didn’t read. She didn’t engage with the chemistry.
She didn’t address a single scientific point. She went straight for the laziest possible dismissal, and even got that wrong.
After reading her response we decided to read her other articles. We wanted to be fair, maybe the magnesium piece was an outlier? Maybe her other work was more rigorous? Maybe we’d misjudged her?
We hadn’t.
What we found left us genuinely flabbergasted! And the deeper we went, the worse it got.
Iodine — an essential nutrient your thyroid literally cannot function without. Declared poison that turns you into a “radioactive 5G antenna.” Within this article she attacked Professor Dolores Cahill, a woman who sacrificed her entire academic career for truth, calling her controlled opposition (oh the irony).
Vitamin D — which your body produces from sunlight and which deficiency of causes rickets and a cascade of health problems. Branded “rat poison.” Yes, cholecalciferol is used in rodenticides, alongside bromethalin, a neurotoxin that causes paralysis, strychnine, which kills by asphyxiation, and zinc phosphide, which releases toxic gas in the stomach. Funny how she only mentions the one that’s also a vitamin. Rodenticide baits contain cholecalciferol at concentrations designed to overwhelm a small rodent’s calcium metabolism. A therapeutic human dose is 1,000–10,000 IU. To reach the equivalent lethal dose used on rats, a 70kg person would need to swallow roughly 120 million IU in one sitting — that’s around twelve thousand supplement capsules at once. By her logic, water is poison too as you can drown in it. (An article explaining the “Vitamin D is rat poison” narrative more fully is in the pipeline).
Vitamin B12 — essential for neurological function, red blood cell production, and DNA synthesis. Declared satanic. Literally. “The Satanic Roots of B12.” Her argument runs like this: B12 supplements are produced by bacterial fermentation. Bacteria exist in soil. Sewage treatment plants also contain bacteria. Therefore B12 is made from sewage sludge, and sewage is satanic. There is a grain of truth buried in there. A 1953 US patent does exist for extracting B12 from activated sewage sludge, but it was for animal feed, not human supplements, and the process hasn’t been used in decades. Modern B12 is produced by culturing specific bacterial strains in controlled, sterile fermentation environments, the same basic process used to make yoghurt, kombucha, or probiotics. But Medicine Girl found a 73-year-old patent for pig feed and presented it as though that’s how your supplement is made today. Meanwhile, she proudly eats “pristine forest floor soil” for her minerals (untested, unpurified dirt from the ground), whilst telling her readers that laboratory-tested, bacterially-fermented B12 is demonic.
DMSO — one of the most promising suppressed therapies in medical history, backed by Dr. Stanley Jacob’s extraordinary research. This is attacked as “paper mill poison.” She went after Amandha Vollmer personally, and when Amandha’s representative sent a standard cease-and-desist, Medicine Girl published the private correspondence and mocked it.
Castor oil — used therapeutically for thousands of years across virtually every culture on Earth. Dismissed as an industrial torture device. She attacked Barbara O’Neil, one of the most compassionate health educators alive, for recommending castor oil packs.
Methylene blue — with over a century of peer-reviewed research demonstrating mitochondrial support and neuroprotective properties. Equated with Red Dye #40 because “both are made the same way.” They’re not. That’s like saying bread and concrete are identical because both involve mixing dry ingredients with liquid.
Colloidal silver — she claimed it turns you into a “human antenna” for 5G networks and enables “Voice-to-Skull mind control.” Then in the same article admitted she still uses silver for wound care because “it works.” You cannot have it both ways.
Chlorine dioxide — she branded it a “bleach cult” and told her readers not to prepare for emergencies, whilst admitting she keeps her own supply for “when the grid goes down.” Rules for thee, not for me.
Homeopathy — a 230-year-old system of medicine used by millions worldwide. Declared satanic Freemasonic black magic. Samuel Hahnemann, the founder of homeopathy, was a Freemason, therefore homeopathy is witchcraft. Now, we’re not naive about Freemasonry and its role at the higher levels, but dismissing an entire system of medicine because its founder had a lodge membership is not critical thinking, it’s guilt by association. It’s attacking the man instead of addressing whether the medicine actually works. And she never does address that, across three entire articles. She never once explains how homeopathy works on animals — dogs, cats, horses — who don’t read testimonials, don’t believe in sugar pills, and don’t consent to Freemasonic rituals.
Every cheap intervention. Every accessible therapy. Every genuine practitioner who dares to help people outside the pharmaceutical model. Attacked, dismissed, and smeared.
And then she went further.
She published a series called “The Periodic Fable of Elements” arguing that the periodic table itself — the organisational framework of all known matter, validated by every scientific discovery since 1869 — is a corporate branding tool. A “fable.” Most elements “don’t actually exist” in nature, apparently. They’re merely “laboratory outputs.”
Magnesium is “actually manganese,” she tells us. Magnesium is element 12. Manganese is element 25. Different atomic structures, different properties, different biological functions entirely. This isn’t a matter of interpretation, it’s like confusing a cat with a giraffe.
Oxygen doesn’t exist as a separate gas, she claims. It’s just “denser air.” Oxygen — the thing she administered to patients as a nurse. The thing pulse oximeters measure. The thing keeping her alive as she typed the article, she is denying its existence.
Water is not H₂O, apparently. It’s just water. A “primary substance” that cannot be broken into hydrogen and oxygen, despite electrolysis being demonstrated in school laboratories worldwide since the 1800s.
This is the person telling you not to take magnesium.
The contradictions pile up across her work in ways that are almost impressive. She says the periodic table is fake, but uses chemistry to argue supplements are toxic. You can’t simultaneously claim chemistry is a lie and use chemistry to make your case. She says homeopathic remedies are “just sugar pills” that do nothing, but also says they’re powerful satanic ritual objects that harvest spiritual consent. They can’t be both inert and spiritually potent. She tells people not to trust their own results. If you took magnesium and felt better, you’re deluded; if homeopathy helped your child, it’s placebo; if DMSO relieved your pain, you’re a victim of marketing. Your lived experience counts for nothing. Only her interpretation matters.
So who benefits from all of this?
Not the people scared away from addressing genuine deficiencies. Not the parents terrified that iodine will make their children radioactive. Not the person with a dental abscess who won’t try the one thing that might help because someone called it a “bleach cult.”
The pharmaceutical industry benefits. Every person scared away from a cheap supplement is a potential customer for an expensive prescription. Every practitioner smeared is one less voice offering alternatives. Every natural therapy demonised is one fewer competitor.
Medicine Girl says she’s not a shill because she tells people to “heal themselves.” But what has she actually left them with? She’s demolished every tool, every therapy, every practitioner, every system of knowledge. Walk barefoot. Eat vegetables. Eat dirt from the forest floor. And subscribe to her Substack.
That’s not health freedom.
We believe in real health freedom — the kind that gives you accurate information and trusts you to make your own decisions. So we’re spending some time writing further articles to counter her more dangerous claims. Not because we enjoy internet arguments, but because real people are making real health decisions based on her misinformation.
Next up is iodine because the deficiency crisis is real and the fear-mongering is potentially harming people,
Stay tuned for our upcoming Iodine articles.
source clivedecarle.substack.com